Colloidal crystal

A colloidal crystal is an ordered array of colloid particles and fine grained materials analogous to a standard crystal whose repeating subunits are atoms or molecules.[1] A natural example of this phenomenon can be found in the gem opal, where spheres of silica assume a close-packed locally periodic structure under moderate compression.[2][3] Bulk properties of a colloidal crystal depend on composition, particle size, packing arrangement, and degree of regularity. Applications include photonics, materials processing, and the study of self-assembly and phase transitions.
A collection of small 2D colloidal crystals with grain boundaries between them. Spherical glass particles (10 μm diameter) in water.
The connectivity of the crystals in the colloidal crystals above. Connections in white indicate that particle has six equally spaced neighbours and therefore forms part of a crystalline domain.
IUPAC definition
Assembly of colloid particles with a periodic structure that
conforms to symmetries familiar from molecular or atomic crystals. Note: Colloidal crystals may be formed in a liquid medium or during
drying of particle suspension.[4]

Introduction

A colloidal crystal is a highly ordered array of particles which can be formed over a long range (to about a centimeter). Arrays such as this appear to be analogous to their atomic or molecular counterparts with proper scaling considerations. A good natural example of this phenomenon can be found in precious opal, where brilliant regions of pure spectral color result from close-packed domains of colloidal spheres of amorphous silicon dioxide, SiO2 (see above illustration). The spherical particles precipitate in highly siliceous pools and form highly ordered arrays after years of sedimentation and compression under hydrostatic and gravitational forces. The periodic arrays of spherical particles make similar arrays of interstitial voids, which act as a natural diffraction grating for light waves in photonic crystals, especially when the interstitial spacing is of the same order of magnitude as the incident lightwave. [5][6]
Origins

The origins of colloidal crystals go back to the mechanical properties of bentonite sols, and the optical properties of Schiller layers in iron oxide sols. The properties are supposed to be due to the ordering of monodisperse inorganic particles.[7] Monodisperse colloids, capable of forming long-range ordered arrays, existing in nature. The discovery by W.M. Stanley of the crystalline forms of the tobacco and tomato viruses provided examples of this. Using X-ray diffraction methods, it was subsequently determined that when concentrated by centrifuging from dilute water suspensions, these virus particles often organized themselves into highly ordered arrays.

Rod-shaped particles in the tobacco mosaic virus could form a two-dimensional triangular lattice, while a body-centered cubic structure was formed from the almost spherical particles in the tomato Bushy Stunt Virus.[8] In 1957, a letter describing the discovery of "A Crystallizable Insect Virus" was published in the journal Nature.[9] Known as the Tipula Iridescent Virus, from both square and triangular arrays occurring on crystal faces, the authors deduced the face-centered cubic close-packing of virus particles. This type of ordered array has also been observed in cell suspensions, where the symmetry is well adapted to the mode of reproduction of the organism.[10] The limited content of genetic material places a restriction on the size of the protein to be coded by it. The use of a large number of the same proteins to build a protective shell is consistent with the limited length of RNA or DNA content.[11][12]

It has been known for many years that, due to repulsive Coulombic interactions, electrically charged macromolecules in an aqueous environment can exhibit long-range crystal-like correlations with interparticle separation distances often being considerably greater than the individual particle diameter. In all of the cases in nature, the same iridescence is caused by the diffraction and constructive interference of visible lightwaves which falls under Bragg’s law.

Because of the rarity and pathological properties, neither opal nor any of the organic viruses have been very popular in scientific laboratories. The number of experiments exploring the physics and chemistry of these “colloidal crystals” has emerged as a result of the simple methods which have evolved in 20 years for preparing synthetic monodisperse colloids, both polymer and mineral, and, through various mechanisms, implementing and preserving their long-range order formation.
Trends

Colloidal crystals are receiving increased attention, largely due to their mechanisms of ordering and self-assembly, cooperative motion, structures similar to those observed in condensed matter by both liquids and solids, and structural phase transitions.[13][14] Phase equilibrium has been considered within the context of their physical similarities, with appropriate scaling, to elastic solids. Observations of the interparticle separation distance has shown a decrease on ordering. This led to a re-evaluation of Langmuir's beliefs about the existence of a long-range attractive component in the interparticle potential.[15]

Colloidal crystals have found application in optics as photonic crystals. Photonics is the science of generating, controlling, and detecting photons (packets of light), particularly in the visible and near Infrared, but also extending to the Ultraviolet, Infrared and far IR portions of the electromagnetic spectrum. The science of photonics includes the emission, transmission, amplification, detection, modulation, and switching of lightwaves over a broad range of frequencies and wavelengths. Photonic devices include electro-optic components such as lasers (Light Amplification by Stimulated Emission of Radiation) and optical fiber. Applications include telecommunications, information processing, illumination, spectroscopy, holography, medicine (surgery, vision correction, endoscopy), military (guided missile) technology, agriculture and robotics.

Polycrystalline colloidal structures have been identified as the basic elements of submicrometre colloidal materials science. [16] Molecular self-assembly has been observed in various biological systems and underlies the formation of a wide variety of complex biological structures. This includes an emerging class of mechanically superior biomaterials based on microstructure features and designs found in nature.

The principal mechanical characteristics and structures of biological ceramics, polymer composites, elastomers, and cellular materials are being re-evaluated, with an emphasis on bioinspired materials and structures. Traditional approaches focus on design methods of biological materials using conventional synthetic materials.[17] The uses have been identified in the synthesis of bioinspired materials through processes that are characteristic of biological systems in nature. This includes the nanoscale self-assembly of the components and the development of hierarchical structures.[18]
Bulk crystals
Aggregation

Aggregation in colloidal dispersions (or stable suspensions) has been characterized by the degree of interparticle attraction.[19] For attractions strong relative to the thermal energy (given by kT), Brownian motion produces irreversibly flocculated structures with growth rates limited by the rate of particle diffusion. This leads to a description using such parameters as the degree of branching, ramification or fractal dimensionality. A reversible growth model has been constructed by modifying the cluster-cluster aggregation model with a finite inter-particle attraction energy.[20][21]

In systems where forces of attraction forces are buffered to some degree, a balance of forces leads to an equilibrium phase separation, that is particles coexist with equal chemical potential in two distinct structural phases. The role of the ordered phase as an elastic colloidal solid has been evidenced by the elastic (or reversible) deformation due to the force of gravity. This deformation can be quantified by the distortion of the lattice parameter, or inter-particle spacing.[22]
Viscoelasticity

Periodic ordered lattices behave as linear viscoelastic solids when subjected to small amplitude mechanical deformations. Okano's group experimentally correlated the shear modulus to the frequency of standing shear modes using mechanical resonance techniques in the ultrasonic range (40 to 70 kHz).[23][24] In oscillatory experiments at lower frequencies (< 40 Hz), the fundamental mode of vibration as well as several higher frequency partial overtones (or harmonics) have been observed. Structurally, most systems exhibit a clear instability toward the formation of periodic domains of relatively short-range order Above a critical amplitude of oscillation, plastic deformation is the primary mode of structural rearrangement.[25]
Phase transitions

Equilibrium phase transitions (e.g. order/disorder), an equation of state, and the kinetics of colloidal crystallization have all been actively studied, leading to the development of several methods to control the self-assembly of the colloidal particles.[26] Examples include colloidal epitaxy and space-based reduced-gravity techniques, as well as the use of temperature gradients to define a density gradient.[27] This is somewhat counterintuitive as temperature does not play a role in determining the hard-sphere phase diagram. However, hard-sphere single crystals (size 3 mm) have been obtained from a sample in a concentration regime that would remain in the liquid state in the absence of a temperature gradient.[28]
Phonon dispersion

Using a single colloidal crystal, phonon dispersion of the normal modes of vibration modes were investigated using photon correlation spectroscopy, or dynamic light scattering. This technique relies on the relaxation or decay of concentration (or density) fluctuations. These are often associated with longitudinal modes in the acoustic range. A distinctive increase in the sound wave velocity (and thus the elastic modulus) by a factor of 2.5 has been observed at the structural transition from colloidal liquid to colloidal solid, or point of ordering.[29][30]
Kossel lines

Using a single body-centered cubic colloidal crystal, the occurrence of Kossel lines in diffraction patterns were used to monitor the initial nucleation and subsequent motion caused distortion of the crystal. Continuous or homogeneous deformations occurring beyond the elastic limit produce a 'flowing crystal', where the nucleation site density increases significantly with increasing particle concentration.[31] Lattice dynamics have been investigated for longitudinal as well as transverse modes. The same technique was used to evaluate the crystallization process near the edge of a glass tube. The former might be considered analogous to a homogeneous nucleation event—whereas the latter would clearly be considered a heterogeneous nucleation event, being catalyzed by the surface of the glass tube.
Growth rates

Small-angle laser light scattering has provided information about spatial density fluctuations or the shape of growing crystal grains.[31][32] In addition, confocal laser scanning microscopy has been used to observe crystal growth near a glass surface. Electro-optic shear waves have been induced by an ac pulse, and monitored by reflection spectroscopy as well as light scattering. Kinetics of colloidal crystallization have been measured quantitatively, with nucleation rates being depending on the suspension concentration.[33][34][35] Similarly, crystal growth rates have been shown to decrease linearly with increasing reciprocal concentration.
Microgravity

Experiments performed in microgravity on the Space Shuttle Columbia suggest that the typical face-centered cubic structure may be induced by gravitational stresses. Crystals tend to exhibit the hcp structure alone (random stacking of hexagonally close-packed crystal planes), in contrast with a mixture of (rhcp) and face-centred cubic packing when allowed sufficient time to reach mechanical equilibrium under gravitational forces on Earth.[36] Glassy (disordered or amorphous) colloidal samples have become fully crystallized in microgravity in less than two weeks.
Thin films

Two-dimensional (thin film) semi-ordered lattices have been studied using an optical microscope, as well as those collected at electrode surfaces. Digital video microscopy has revealed the existence of an equilibrium hexatic phase as well as a strongly first-order liquid-to-hexatic and hexatic-to-solid phase transition.[37] These observations are in agreement with the explanation that melting might proceed via the unbinding of pairs of lattice dislocations.
Long-range order

Long-range order has been observed in thin films of colloidal liquids under oil—with the faceted edge of an emerging single crystal in alignment with the diffuse streaking pattern in the liquid phase. Structural defects have been directly observed in the ordered solid phase as well as at the interface of the solid and liquid phases. Mobile lattice defects have been observed via Bragg reflections, due to the modulation of the light waves in the strain field of the defect and its stored elastic strain energy.[16]
Mobile lattice defects

All of the experiments have led to at least one common conclusion: colloidal crystals may indeed mimic their atomic counterparts on appropriate scales of length (spatial) and time (temporal). Defects have been reported to flash by in the blink of an eye in thin films of colloidal crystals under oil using a simple optical microscope. But quantitatively measuring the rate of its propagation provides an entirely different challenge, which has been measured at somewhere near the speed of sound.
Non-spherical colloid based crystals

Crystalline thin-films from non-spherical colloids were produced using convective assembly techniques. Colloid shapes included dumbbell, hemisphere, disc, and sphero-cylinder shapes.[38][39] Both purely crystalline and plastic crystal phases could be produced, depending on the aspect ratio of the colloidal particle. The low aspect ratio, such as bulge, eye-ball, and snowman-like non-spherical colloids, which spontaneously self-assembled to photonic crystal array with high uniformity.[40] The particles were crystallized both as 2D (i.e., monolayer) and 3D (i.e., multilayer) structures.[41][42][43][44][45] The observed lattice and particle orientations experimentally confirmed a body of theoretical work on the condensed phases of non-spherical objects. Assembly of crystals from non-spherical colloids can also be directed via the use of electrical fields.[46]
Applications
Photonics

Technologically, colloidal crystals have found application in the world of optics as photonic band gap (PBG) materials (or photonic crystals). Synthetic opals as well as inverse opal configurations are being formed either by natural sedimentation or applied forces, both achieving similar results: long-range ordered structures which provide a natural diffraction grating for lightwaves of wavelength comparable to the particle size.[47]

Novel PBG materials are being formed from opal-semiconductor-polymer composites, typically utilizing the ordered lattice to create an ordered array of holes (or pores) which is left behind after removal or decomposition of the original particles. Residual hollow honeycomb structures provide a relative index of refraction (ratio of matrix to air) sufficient for selective filters. Variable index liquids or liquid crystals injected into the network alter the ratio and band gap.

Such frequency-sensitive devices may be ideal for optical switching and frequency selective filters in the ultraviolet, visible, or infrared portions of the spectrum, as well as higher efficiency antennae at microwave and millimeter wave frequencies.
Self-assembly

Self-assembly is the most common term in use in the modern scientific community to describe the spontaneous aggregation of particles (atoms, molecules, colloids, micelles, etc.) without the influence of any external forces.[18] Large groups of such particles are known to assemble themselves into thermodynamically stable, structurally well-defined arrays, quite reminiscent of one of the 7 crystal systems found in metallurgy and mineralogy (e.g. face-centered cubic, body-centered cubic, etc.). The fundamental difference in equilibrium structure is in the spatial scale of the unit cell (or lattice parameter) in each particular case.

Molecular self-assembly is found widely in biological systems and provides the basis of a wide variety of complex biological structures. This includes an emerging class of mechanically superior biomaterials based on microstructural features and designs found in nature. Thus, self-assembly is also emerging as a new strategy in chemical synthesis and nanotechnology.[17] Molecular crystals, liquid crystals, colloids, micelles, emulsions, phase-separated polymers, thin films and self-assembled monolayers all represent examples of the types of highly ordered structures which are obtained using these techniques. The distinguishing feature of these methods is self-organization.
See also

Crystal growth
Crystal structure
Ceramic engineering
Diffusion-limited aggregation
Nanomaterials
Nanoparticle
Nucleation
Photonic crystal
Opal
Sol-gel

References

Pieranski, Pawel (1983). "Colloidal crystals". Contemporary Physics. 24: 25–73. Bibcode:1983ConPh..24...25P. doi:10.1080/00107518308227471.
Jones, J. B.; Sanders, J. V.; Segnit, E. R. (1964). "Structure of Opal". Nature. 204 (4962): 990. Bibcode:1964Natur.204..990J. doi:10.1038/204990a0.
Darragh, P.J., et al., Opal, Scientific American, Vol. 234, p. 84, (1976)
Slomkowski, Stanislaw; Alemán, José V; Gilbert, Robert G; Hess, Michael; Horie, Kazuyuki; Jones, Richard G; Kubisa, Przemyslaw; Meisel, Ingrid; Mormann, Werner; Penczek, Stanisław; Stepto, Robert F. T (2011). "Terminology of polymers and polymerization processes in dispersed systems (IUPAC Recommendations 2011)" (PDF). Pure and Applied Chemistry. 83 (12): 2229–2259. doi:10.1351/PAC-REC-10-06-03.
Luck, W. (1963). "Über Bragg-Reflexe mit sichtbarem Licht an monodispersen Kunststofflatices. II". Berichte der Bunsengesellschaft für physikalische Chemie. 67: 84. doi:10.1002/bbpc.19630670114.
Hiltner, P. Anne; Krieger, Irvin M. (1969). "Diffraction of light by ordered suspensions". The Journal of Physical Chemistry. 73 (7): 2386. doi:10.1021/j100727a049.
Langmuir, Irving (1938). "The Role of Attractive and Repulsive Forces in the Formation of Tactoids, Thixotropic Gels, Protein Crystals and Coacervates". The Journal of Chemical Physics. 6 (12): 873–896. Bibcode:1938JChPh...6..873L. doi:10.1063/1.1750183.
Bernal, J. D.; Fankuchen, I (1941). "X-Ray and Crystallographic Studies of Plant Virus Preparations: I. Introduction and Preparation of Specimens Ii. Modes of Aggregation of the Virus Particles". The Journal of General Physiology. 25 (1): 111–46. doi:10.1085/jgp.25.1.111. PMC 2142030. PMID 19873255.
Williams, Robley C.; Smith, Kenneth M. (1957). "A Crystallizable Insect Virus". Nature. 179 (4551): 119–20. Bibcode:1957Natur.179..119W. doi:10.1038/179119a0. PMID 13400114.
Watson, J.D., Molecular Biology of the Gene, Benjamin, Inc. (1970)
Stanley, W.M. (1937). "Crystalline Form of the Tobacco Mosaic Virus Protein". American Journal of Botany. 24 (2): 59–68. doi:10.2307/2436720. JSTOR 2436720.
Nobel Lecture: The Isolation and Properties of Crystalline TMV (1946)
Murray, Cherry A.; Grier, David G. (1996). "Video Microscopy of Monodisperse Colloidal Systems". Annual Review of Physical Chemistry. 47: 421–462. Bibcode:1996ARPC...47..421M. doi:10.1146/annurev.physchem.47.1.421.
Grier, David G.; Murray, Cherry A. (1994). "The microscopic dynamics of freezing in supercooled colloidal fluids". The Journal of Chemical Physics. 100 (12): 9088. Bibcode:1994JChPh.100.9088G. doi:10.1063/1.466662.
Russel, W.B., et al., Eds. Colloidal Dispersions (Cambridge Univ. Press, 1989) [see cover]
Ref.14 in Mangels, J.A. and Messing, G.L., Eds., Forming of Ceramics, Microstructural Control Through Colloidal Consolidation, I.A. Aksay, Advances in Ceramics, Vol. 9, p. 94, Proc. Amer. Ceramic Soc. (1984)
Whitesides, G.; Mathias, J.; Seto, C. (1991). "Molecular self-assembly and nanochemistry: A chemical strategy for the synthesis of nanostructures". Science. 254 (5036): 1312–9. Bibcode:1991Sci...254.1312W. doi:10.1126/science.1962191. PMID 1962191.
Dabbs, Daniel M.; Aksay, Ilhan A. (2000). "Self-Assembledceramicsproduced Bycomplex-Fluidtemplation". Annual Review of Physical Chemistry. 51 (1): 601–22. Bibcode:2000ARPC...51..601D. doi:10.1146/annurev.physchem.51.1.601. PMID 11031294. S2CID 14113689.
Aubert, Claude; Cannell, David (1986). "Restructuring of colloidal silica aggregates". Physical Review Letters. 56 (7): 738–741. Bibcode:1986PhRvL..56..738A. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.56.738. PMID 10033272.
Witten, T.; Sander, L. (1981). "Diffusion-Limited Aggregation, a Kinetic Critical Phenomenon". Physical Review Letters. 47 (19): 1400. Bibcode:1981PhRvL..47.1400W. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.47.1400.
Witten, T.; Sander, L. (1983). "Diffusion-limited aggregation". Physical Review B. 27 (9): 5686. Bibcode:1983PhRvB..27.5686W. doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.27.5686. S2CID 120588585.
Crandall, R. S.; Williams, R. (1977). "Gravitational Compression of Crystallized Suspensions of Polystyrene Spheres". Science. 198 (4314): 293–5. Bibcode:1977Sci...198..293C. doi:10.1126/science.198.4314.293. PMID 17770503.
Mitaku, Shigeki; Ohtsuki, Toshiya; Enari, Katsumi; Kishimoto, Akihiko; Okano, Koji (1978). "Studies of Ordered Monodisperse Polystyrene Latexes. I. Shear Ultrasonic Measurements". Japanese Journal of Applied Physics. 17 (2): 305. Bibcode:1978JaJAP..17..305M. doi:10.1143/JJAP.17.305.
Ohtsuki, Toshiya; Mitaku, Sigeki; Okano, Koji (1978). "Studies of Ordered Monodisperse Latexes. II. Theory of Mechanical Properties". Japanese Journal of Applied Physics. 17 (4): 627. Bibcode:1978JaJAP..17..627O. doi:10.1143/JJAP.17.627.
Russel, W (1981). "The viscoelastic properties of ordered latices: A self-consistent field theory". Journal of Colloid and Interface Science. 83 (1): 163–177. Bibcode:1981JCIS...83..163R. doi:10.1016/0021-9797(81)90021-7.
Phan, See-Eng; Russel, William; Cheng, Zhengdong; Zhu, Jixiang; Chaikin, Paul; Dunsmuir, John; Ottewill, Ronald (1996). "Phase transition, equation of state, and limiting shear viscosities of hard sphere dispersions". Physical Review E. 54 (6): 6633. Bibcode:1996PhRvE..54.6633P. doi:10.1103/PhysRevE.54.6633. PMID 9965889.
Chaikin, P. M.; Cheng, Zhengdong; Russel, William B. (1999). "Controlled growth of hard-sphere colloidal crystals". Nature. 401 (6756): 893. Bibcode:1999Natur.401..893C. doi:10.1038/44785.
Davis, K. E.; Russel, W. B.; Glantschnig, W. J. (1989). "Disorder-to-Order Transition in Settling Suspensions of Colloidal Silica: X-ray Measurements". Science. 245 (4917): 507–10. Bibcode:1989Sci...245..507D. doi:10.1126/science.245.4917.507. PMID 17750261.
Cheng, Zhengdong; Zhu, Jixiang; Russel, William; Chaikin, P. (2000). "Phonons in an Entropic Crystal". Physical Review Letters. 85 (7): 1460–3. Bibcode:2000PhRvL..85.1460C. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.85.1460. PMID 10970529.
Penciu, R. S; Kafesaki, M; Fytas, G; Economou, E. N; Steffen, W; Hollingsworth, A; Russel, W. B (2002). "Phonons in colloidal crystals". Europhysics Letters (EPL). 58 (5): 699. Bibcode:2002EL.....58..699P. doi:10.1209/epl/i2002-00322-3.
Sogami, I. S.; Yoshiyama, T. (1990). "Kossel line analysis on crystallization in colloidal suspensions". Phase Transitions. 21 (2–4): 171. doi:10.1080/01411599008206889.
Schätzel, Klaus (1993). "Light scattering – diagnostic methods for colloidal dispersions". Advances in Colloid and Interface Science. 46: 309–332. doi:10.1016/0001-8686(93)80046-E.
Ito, Kensaku; Okumura, Hiroya; Yoshida, Hiroshi; Ise, Norio (1990). "Growth of local structure in colloidal suspensions". Physical Review B. 41 (8): 5403–5406. Bibcode:1990PhRvB..41.5403I. doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.41.5403. PMID 9994407.
Yoshida, Hiroshi; Ito, Kensaku; Ise, Norio (1991). "Localized ordered structure in polymer latex suspensions as studied by a confocal laser scanning microscope". Physical Review B. 44 (1): 435–438. Bibcode:1991PhRvB..44..435Y. doi:10.1103/PhysRevB.44.435. PMID 9998272.
Yoshida, Hiroshi; Ito, Kensaku; Ise, Norio (1991). "Colloidal crystal growth". Journal of the Chemical Society, Faraday Transactions. 87 (3): 371. doi:10.1039/FT9918700371.
Chaikin, P. M.; Zhu, Jixiang; Li, Min; Rogers, R.; Meyer, W.; Ottewill, R. H.; Sts-73 Space Shuttle Crew; Russel, W. B. (1997). "Crystallization of hard-sphere colloids in microgravity". Nature. 387 (6636): 883. Bibcode:1997Natur.387..883Z. doi:10.1038/43141.
Armstrong, A J; Mockler, R C; O'Sullivan, W J (1989). "Isothermal-expansion melting of two-dimensional colloidal monolayers on the surface of water". Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter. 1 (9): 1707. Bibcode:1989JPCM....1.1707A. doi:10.1088/0953-8984/1/9/015.
Forster, Jason D.; Park, Jin-Gyu; Mittal, Manish; Noh, Heeso; Schreck, Carl F.; O’Hern, Corey S.; Cao, Hui; Furst, Eric M.; Dufresne, Eric R. (2011-08-23). "Assembly of Optical-Scale Dumbbells into Dense Photonic Crystals". ACS Nano. 5 (8): 6695–6700. doi:10.1021/nn202227f. ISSN 1936-0851. PMID 21740047.
Kim, Jin-Woong; Larsen, Ryan J.; Weitz, David A. (2006-11-01). "Synthesis of Nonspherical Colloidal Particles with Anisotropic Properties". Journal of the American Chemical Society. 128 (44): 14374–14377. doi:10.1021/ja065032m. ISSN 0002-7863. PMID 17076511.
Vasantha, Vivek Arjunan; Rusli, Wendy; Junhui, Chen; Wenguang, Zhao; Sreekanth, Kandammathe Valiyaveedu; Singh, Ranjan; Parthiban, Anbanandam (2019-08-29). "Highly monodisperse zwitterion functionalized non-spherical polymer particles with tunable iridescence". RSC Advances. 9 (47): 27199–27207. doi:10.1039/C9RA05162G. ISSN 2046-2069.
Hosein, Ian D.; Liddell, Chekesha M. (2007). "Convectively Assembled Asymmetric Dimer-Based Colloidal Crystals". Langmuir. 23 (21): 10479–85. doi:10.1021/la7007254. PMID 17629310.
Hosein, Ian D.; Liddell, Chekesha M. (2007). "Convectively Assembled nonspherical Mushroom Cap-Based Colloidal Crystals". Langmuir. 23 (17): 8810–4. doi:10.1021/la700865t. PMID 17630788.
Hosein, Ian D.; John, Bettina S.; Lee, Stephanie H.; Escobedo, Fernando A.; Liddell, Chekesha M. (2009). "Rotator and crystalline films via self-assembly of short-bond-length colloidal dimers". Journal of Materials Chemistry. 19 (3): 344. doi:10.1039/B818613H.
Hosein, Ian D.; Lee, Stephanie H.; Liddell, Chekesha M. (2010). "Dimer-Based Three-Dimensional Photonic Crystals". Advanced Functional Materials. 20 (18): 3085. doi:10.1002/adfm.201000134.
Vasantha, Vivek Arjunan; Rusli, Wendy; Junhui, Chen; Wenguang, Zhao; Sreekanth, Kandammathe Valiyaveedu; Singh, Ranjan; Parthiban, Anbanandam (2019-08-29). "Highly monodisperse zwitterion functionalized non-spherical polymer particles with tunable iridescence". RSC Advances. 9 (47): 27199–27207. doi:10.1039/C9RA05162G. ISSN 2046-2069.
Forster, Jason D.; Park, Jin-Gyu; Mittal, Manish; Noh, Heeso; Schreck, Carl F.; O’Hern, Corey S.; Cao, Hui; Furst, Eric M.; Dufresne, Eric R. (2011-08-23). "Assembly of Optical-Scale Dumbbells into Dense Photonic Crystals". ACS Nano. 5 (8): 6695–6700. doi:10.1021/nn202227f. ISSN 1936-0851. PMID 21740047.

Lova, Paola; Congiu, Simone; Sparnacci, Katia; Angelini, Angelo; Boarino, Luca; Laus, Michele; Stasio, Francesco Di; Comoretto, Davide (8 April 2020). "Core–shell silica–rhodamine B nanosphere for synthetic opals: from fluorescence spectral redistribution to sensing". RSC Advances. 10 (25): 14958–14964. doi:10.1039/D0RA02245D. ISSN 2046-2069.