The Continence of Scipio

The Continence of Scipio, or alternatively The Clemency of Scipio, is a episode recounted by Livy of the Roman general Scipio Africanus during his campaign in Spain during the Second Punic War. He refused a generous ransom for a young female prisoner, returning her to her fiance Allucius, who in return became a supporter of Rome. In recognition of his magnanimous treatment of a prisoner, he was taken as one of the prime examples of mercy during warfare in classical times. Interest in the story revived in the Renaissance and the episode figured widely thereafter in both the literary and figurative arts.

The Continence Of Scipio, Georg Mathias Fuchs

The Continence of Scipio, Francesco Lorenzi

The Continence Of Scipio, Vincenzo Camuccini

The Continence of Scipio, Johann Rudolf Byss

The Continence of Scipio, Giovanni Antonio Pellegrini

The Continence of Scipio, Johann Heiss

The Continence of Scipio, Giacinto Diano

The Continence of Scipio, Gerbrand van den Eeckhout

Palazzo Bindi Segardi : The continence of Scipio, Domenico Beccafumi

The Continence of Scipio, Nicolas Poussin

Generosity of Scipio, Amico Aspertini

The Continence of Scipio, Niccolò dell' Abbate

See also : Roman Empire, Paintings, Drawings

The classical story

The story related by Livy in his history of Rome was followed by all later writers, although it is recorded that the earlier historian Valerius Antias took a dissenting view.[1] According to Livy's account of the siege of the Carthaginian colony of New Carthage, the Celtiberian prince Allucius was betrothed to a beautiful virgin who was taken prisoner by Scipio Africanus in 209 BC. Despite having a reputation for womanizing, instead of the usual brutal treatment given to attractive female "barbarian" prisoners, Scipio summoned her parents and fiance, who arrived with a ransom of treasure. Scipio refused this and returned her to them, asking only that they be friends to Rome. When they offered the ransom as a present, he accepted it, only to return it immediately as a wedding gift from himself. Allucius then brought over his tribe to support the Roman armies in gratitude.[2][3][4]
Early modern treatments
Literature and opera

This episode was a popular motif for exemplary literature from that time on, growing to a peak of popularity during the 17th and 18th centuries. Prior to this period, it was given pride of place in the story of Scipio inserted into translations of Plutarch’s Lives that was written originally by the Dutchman Carolus Clusius in 1567.[5] Among dramatic treatments of the story, one of the foremost was the Scipion of Jean Desmarets (1638), which was then adapted into Dutch by Jan Lemmers as Schipio in Karthago (1649) and also performed later as Schipio en Olinde. In England a verse drama on the episode, Scipio Africanus, was chiefly distinguished by being the work of a schoolboy, Charles Beckingham. It was acted and later printed in 1718.

Operatic treatments were numerous, with several composers setting the same libretto. So, for example, Nicolo Minato's Scipione Africano was set, or served as the basis for adaptations, by Francesco Cavalli (1662); Carlo Ambrogio Lonati (1692); Francesco Bianchi (1787); and Gioacchino Albertini (1789). In addition there was Johann Sigismund Kusser's German version, Der großmütige Scipio Africanus (1694). Giovanni Battista Boccabadati's prose drama Scipione (1693) served as the basis for Apostolo Zeno's Scipione nelle Spagne. This was performed in 1710, with music possibly by Antonio Caldara, and was also set by Alessandro Scarlatti (1714), Tomaso Albinoni (1724), George Friederic Handel (1726), Carlo Arrigoni (1739), and Leonardo Lego (1740). Johann Christian Bach's La Clemenza di Scipione (1778) was also based upon it.
Visual arts

There were numerous artistic depictions of the mercy and sexual restraint of Scipio although, as with the operas, they go now by a variety of titles. "The Continence of Scipio" is commonest in English, although "The Clemency of Scipio" is also found. In other languages the terms magnanimity (großmütigheit) and generosity are alternatives. There is also sometimes a difficulty in identifying which scene is intended. The alternative example of military clemency descending from Classical times was Alexander the Great's generous treatment of the family of the defeated Persian King Darius. The scene of a victorious general seated at the centre of the composition with kneeling figures before him might portray either story without other clues to its interpretation.[6] Typically Scipio sits on a throne on a raised dias, stretching out an arm in the direction of the Spanish party, with their treasure laid out in front of them. The "continence" shown by Scipio is both sexual and financial.[7]
Giovanni Antonio Fasolo's 16th century fresco is to the right of the door at the Castello Porto Colleoni Thiene.

Tapestry series based on the exploits of Scipio, which would often portray this scene, was one contextual identifier; so was connection with the histories of Livy or the expanded Plutarch for which the numerous surviving prints were intended, or on which they were dependent. Another context was the work's association with marriage, since the wedding between Allucius and his bride followed immediately on her restoration to him. Apollonio di Giovanni di Tommaso's episodic depiction appeared as a painted panel on a 15th-century marriage chest.[8] Pietro da Cortona’s mural in the Palazzo Pitti was intended for the marriage of Ferdinando II de' Medici, Grand Duke of Tuscany in 1637. In the case of the 1621 painting of the scene by Anthony van Dyck, which features prominently George Villiers, 1st Duke of Buckingham, together with his future bride, the artist's patron was also the sponsor of the marriage. Several other paintings from this time may have similar histories. The connection also extends to literary works, since it is known that Boccabadati's 1693 drama Scipione was written for performance during the celebration of the marriage between Francesco II d'Este, Duke of Modena and Margherita Maria Farnese.[9]

A large number of paintings of Scipio's act of clemency were produced in Europe - over a hundred by Low Countries artists alone.[10] Some artists made a speciality of the subject, returning to it more than once. Frans Francken the Younger painted eight versions, Sebastiano Ricci six versions, Simon de Vos and Gerbrand van den Eeckhout four each. Joseph-Marie Vien painted two versions, as did Peter Paul Rubens. In the case of the latter, both paintings were subsequently destroyed. Beside the historical record, a sketch of the 1620 version remains, as does a copy now in Lacock Abbey.[11] There are also 16th century frescos by Gian Battista Zelotti at the Villa Emo, Fanzolo; the Villa Caldogno-Nordera, Caldogna; and elsewhere in Italy.

Paintings
The Clemency of Scipio by Giovanni Domenico Tiepolo (1751), Städel.

Below are listed some of the principal paintings of the subject in museum collections:

Continence of Scipio, Giovanni Bellini (after 1506), National Gallery of Art
The Continence of Scipio Africanus, Domenico Beccafumi (c.1525), Palazzo Manzi, Lucca
The Continence of Scipio, Lambert Lombard (1547), Musée des Beaux-Arts, Rennes
The Continence of Scipio, Nicolò dell'Abbate (1555), Louvre
The Continence of Scipio, Giulio Licinio (after 1566), National Gallery, London
The Continence of Scipio, Karel van Mander (painting on copper, possibly used on a cabinet door, 1600}, Rijksmuseum, Amsterdam
The Continence of Scipio, Anthony Van Dyck (1621), Christ Church, Oxford
The Continence of Scipio, Jan Steen (1629), Cummer Museum of Art and Gardens
The Continence of Scipio, Nicolas Poussin (1645), Louvre
The Continence of Scipio, Gerbrand van den Eeckhout (1669), Musée des Beaux-Arts de Lille
The Clemency of Scipio, Giulio Romano (1688), Louvre
The Continence of Scipio, Giovanni Antonio Pellegrini (c.1708-13), The Cleveland Museum of Art
The Continence of Scipio, François Lemoyne (1726), Museum of Fine Arts of Nancy
The Clemency of Scipio, Michele Rocca (1720), Louvre
The Continence of Scipio, Giambattista Pittoni (1733), Louvre
The Continence of Scipio, Pietro Francesco Guala (1750), Musée départemental de l'Oise, Beauvais
The Clemency of Scipio, Giovanni Domenico Tiepolo (1751), Städel
The Continence of Scipio, Pompeo Batoni (1771 or 1772), Hermitage Museum
The Continence of Scipio, David Allan, 1774, National Gallery of Scotland
The Continence of Scipio, Jean-Germain Drouais (1784), Musée des Beaux-Arts, Rennes
The Continence of Scipio, Joshua Reynolds (1789), Hermitage Museum
The Continence of Scipio, Paul Chenavard (1848), Museum of Fine Arts of Lyon

Notes

Kunzle, p.550
Ab urbe condita Book 26, chapter 50
Valerius Maximus, iv. 3. § 1
Sil. Ital. xv. 268 &c
Kunzle, p.519
Kunzle, p.524
Kunzle
Victoria and Albert Museum
Dizionario Biografico degli Italiani - Volume 10 (1968)
Kunzle p.565ff

References

Kunzle, David (ed.), “The Magnanimous Soldier: The Continence of Scipio Africanus” in From Criminal to Courtier: The Soldier in Netherlandish Art 1550–1672, 2002, BRILL, ISBN 9004123695, 9789004123694, pp. 507–71.